16 Butterbeer Recipes Every Harry Potter Fan Will Love 1. These perfect cupcakes that look straight out of Molly Weasley’s kitchen. 2. This wicked cake that would leave Ron speechless. 3. This pumpkin-Butterbeer hot chocolate that’s way better than any love potion. 4. This popcorn that should be sold at Honeydukes. 5. These sandwich cookies you could snack on while studying for your O.W.L.s. 6. These Butterbeer Pocky the trolley lady should definitely sell on the Hogwarts Express. 7. These tarts that would be the perfect teatime treat at the Burrow. 8. These ice cream sandwiches that would make Florean Fortescue proud. 9. This glorious stack of pancakes, worthy of the best Hogwarts feasts. 10. These cupcakes that would make even Vernon Dursley want to join the magic world. 11. These deceptively boozy Butterbeer jello pops that would receive Fred and George’s seal of approval. 12. These Butterbeer pudding cookies that are guaranteed to be better than Hagrid’s cookies. 13. These cookies that should be served as a snack at the Three Broomsticks. 14. This Butterbeer fudge that would definitely make it into Dumbledore’s passwords list. 15. This cake that would fill any Quidditch fan with joy.